A Woman Is No Man: Book Club Introduction • The Humble Pie

❗️Spoiler-Free Intro Post❗️

A Woman is no Man

By Etaf Rum

Some stories are so quietly devastating you almost don’t hear the crack until you’re halfway through.

This is one of those.

For this month’s Book Club selection, we’re reading A Woman Is No Man, a novel that follows three generations of Palestinian-American women navigating the weight of inherited silence, the cost of cultural loyalty, and the impossible choice between family and self.

Without giving anything away, this book is not light. But it is important.

It’s the kind of story that shows us what happens when a woman’s worth is measured by obedience, and what it takes to question the system that raised you, even when that system is wrapped in the language of love, faith, and tradition.

---

Why This Book Matters (And Why I’m Reading It)

I grew up in white evangelical and Catholic spaces. And one of the things I was taught, implicitly and explicitly, was that women in other cultures, especially Muslim women, needed saving. We were told to fear arranged marriages, to pity women in headscarves, to see their traditions as oppressive.

What I didn’t see then, and what this book helped me see now, is how much of that rhetoric was projection.

We were taught to fear the veil while our own silence was stitched into our skin in different ways. The control looked different. The rules were coded differently. But the message was the same: your body is not yours, your voice is not yours, your dreams are selfish.

This book isn’t about one culture or one faith.

It’s about the many ways systems, across religions, across histories, across families, use tradition as a cage for women.

And how hard it is to unlearn what you were taught was sacred.

---

If You’ve Ever…

- Struggled to find your voice in a family that prized survival over self-expression

- Swallowed your truth to stay safe

- Wondered what stories your mother couldn’t tell you

- Felt the weight of being “good” when no one ever asked if you were okay

This book is a door.

You don’t have to analyze it. You don’t have to agree with every choice the characters make.

You just have to be willing to walk through the silence and see what echoes back.

---

How We’ll Approach This Month

As always, there’s no pressure to share anything personal.

You can read in your own time, mark what moves you, or just sit with the story.

We’ll circle back with a companion post after the reading window closes... something that holds space for deeper reflection, character trauma, and intergenerational patterns. That follow-up post will include a spoiler warning and optional prompts for personal or group reflection.

---

Final Note

Some stories heal us by showing what’s possible.

Others heal us by naming what was never allowed.

A Woman Is No Man does both.

Let’s read gently, together.

---

Thank you for reading. If this stirred something in you and you’d like to spend more time with this work, you can explore The Humble Pie 12 Steps and learn more about how I support people as a trauma recovery coach.